Disney Cruise vs Royal Caribbean: Ultimate Comparison

• Facebook
• Instagram
• Amazon
• Pinterest

I’ve absolutely fallen in love with Disney cruises, but I know they come at a higher price point than other cruise lines. I’ve spent a lot of time trying to weigh the pros and cons to really decide if a Disney cruise is worth it. And after cruising with both companies a handful of times, I have lots of notes about the biggest difference when it comes to a Disney cruise vs Royal Caribbean.

Both of these cruise lines offer good cruises for families tailored to different types of travelers. And understanding what sets them apart can help you choose the perfect getaway for your family. I will say that right off the bat, Disney cruises are better for families of 5. Most Royal Caribbean staterooms can only accommodate four people, which means I typically have to book two staterooms for my family of five. Some of the newer, bigger ships have more options, but they’re still limited. Check out my complete analysis on which cruise lines are best for families of 5.

Now let’s dive into a detailed comparison of a Disney cruise vs Royal Caribbean, looking at what’s included, price points, and their ships.

Disney Cruise Vs Royal Caribbean: What’s Included on Each?

Disney Cruise Line

The Disney Cruise Line is known for its exceptional focus on family-friendly experiences, with Disney offers centered on character-driven storytelling, themed entertainment, and magical Disney touches. Your fare includes:

• Dining: Rotational dining at unique themed restaurants (like Animator’s Palate), casual dining, and room service.
• Entertainment: Broadway-caliber Disney stage shows, first-run Disney movies, themed deck parties, and character meet-and-greets with disney characters.
• Kids’ Clubs: Both cruise lines have highly regarded supervised youth programs, but Disney’s Oceaneer Club stands out for immersive themed spaces for different age groups, from toddlers to teens. Its clubs include areas inspired by Star Wars and Toy Story. In the nursery, kids can also get snacks like milk and yogurt.
• Non-Alcoholic Beverages: Complimentary soda, coffee, tea, and water at select locations, and on Disney soda is included in the cruise fare with self-serve soda fountains that are more conveniently located than Royal Caribbean’s.
• Private Island Access: Disney’s Castaway Cay is one of the line’s private islands, with activities like snorkeling, biking, and beachside barbecues.
• Special Events: Disney Cruise Line offers unique themed nights, such as Pirate Night, where guests can dress up as pirates, enjoy a themed dinner, and watch an exclusive fireworks at sea show—something Disney is known for and a highlight of their cruises.

Check out my other popular post for a complete list of what is included on a Disney cruise.

Royal Caribbean

Royal Caribbean appeals to a broader audience than a Disney Cruise and generally offers larger ships with more expansive activity options for families, couples, and adults. Included in your fare:

• Dining: A variety of complimentary options, including the main dining room, the windjammer buffet, and snack spots; Windjammer typically has more variety than Disney’s Cabanas.
• Entertainment: High-energy shows, AquaTheater performances, and live music, plus on applicable ships an ice skating rink used for shows. There are also casinos, which Disney ships do not have.
• Activities: A stronger thrill focus with FlowRider surf simulators, a rock climbing wall, mini-golf, laser tag, and waterslides (availability depends on the ship).
• Kids’ Clubs: Adventure Ocean Club for children ages 3-17, with edutainment programming built into the youth experience.
• Private Island Access: Royal Caribbean’s private island is Perfect Day at Coco Cay on select itineraries, with beaches, a water park, and extra-cost attractions like the hot air balloon ride.

Disney Cruise vs Royal Caribbean: Price Points

Disney Cruise Line tends to have a higher cruise fare, but it’s often justified by the quality of service, attention to detail, and inclusion of magical experiences. On our most recent Royal Caribbean cruise, we kept tracking the differences between Royal and Disney, and often found ourselves saying “that’s a point for Disney.”

• A 3-night Bahamian cruise typically starts around $4,400 for a family of four in an inside stateroom. Pricing can go much higher for balcony cabins or concierge-level suites.
• Longer itineraries and sailings on the newest ship tend to push pricing even higher.
• Rarely have sales, however sometimes there are better times to book Disney cruises than others.

Royal Caribbean is generally the better pick if you want to save money, with lower fares and a broader selection of itineraries.

• A 3-night Bahamian cruise starts around $1,200-$1,500 for a family of four in an inside stateroom. Balcony cabins or suites will increase the price, but they’re often still far less expensive than Disney.
• Sales and promotions are frequent, so you can often find discounted fares or perks like onboard credits.
• Buying beverage packages, including a soda package, ahead of time can also help lower drink costs.

My comparison takeaway

If I had never sailed Disney, I wouldn’t have noticed some of the magical touches missing on Royal Caribbean. For example, Disney cruises would service our room twice a day. They returned the couch bed into a couch during the day, and then while we were at dinner, they would prepare it for sleeping. This second service would include chocolates on the bed and a towel animal. Royal Caribbean serviced our cabin once per day, never left chocolates, and occasionally left a towel animal. Since both lines sometimes visit the same ports, the value onboard can matter more than destination alone.

Ships and Onboard Experiences

Disney Cruise Line

Disney Cruise Line has much fewer ships vs Royal Caribbean. Its fleet consists of eight DCL ships: the Magic, Wonder, Dream, Fantasy, Wish, Adventure, Treasure and Destiny. Each ship is elegantly designed, combining Art Deco or Art Nouveau aesthetics with Disney charm. And Disney focuses more on immersive experiences than adrenaline attractions. Several are smaller ships that feel more intimate than many vessels from other lines. Disney Wonder is one of the classic smaller ships in the fleet. There are also far fewer sailings to choose from.

Highlights of Disney Cruise Line ships include:

• Themed Restaurants: From dining in an “enchanted” garden to enjoying interactive animations. The onboard atmosphere also leans heavily on disney characters, character-driven storytelling, and themed entertainment.
• Aquatic Fun: Waterslides like the AquaDuck (a water coaster) and family pools, with a family-friendly pool deck that includes splash pads for little ones and hot tubs nearby for relaxing.
• Adults-Only Areas: Quiet Cove Pool, fine dining at Palo or Remy (two of the Disney extras I recommend), and chic lounges.
• Staterooms: Spacious and family-focused, with features like split bathrooms and extra storage. Disney staterooms are generally larger than Royal Caribbean’s, and a Disney Deluxe Family Ocean View Stateroom can include a verandah. Disney staterooms can accommodate up to 5 people in a single room, making them ideal for larger families. The split bathroom design—with one side featuring a shower and sink and the other a toilet and sink—adds extra convenience for families getting ready.
• Activities: Disney also offers onboard favorites like animation classes and trivia games.
• Pirate Night & Fireworks: Disney Cruise Line is one of the only cruise lines to offer fireworks at sea. Their famous Pirate Night transforms the ship into a swashbuckling adventure, complete with themed shows, pirate-themed dining, and a spectacular fireworks display over the ocean.

Royal Caribbean

Royal Caribbean’s fleet is vast, with over 25 large ships offering diverse physical activities and extensive amenities, from mid-sized vessels to some of the biggest at sea, like Icon of the Seas. When you go to book the cruise, there are many more options, such as interior balcony rooms (overlooking common spaces of the ship). They feel like cities! The newest ship in the fleet also helps showcase the line’s latest features. Highlights of Royal Caribbean ships include:

• Innovative Activities: Skydiving simulators, zip lines, bumper cars, and escape rooms, which can be especially appealing for older children.
• Neighborhood Concepts: The Oasis-class ships feature themed neighborhoods, such as Central Park and the Boardwalk.
• Aquatic Fun: Massive waterparks, wave pools, and multi-story slides, plus a lively pool deck atmosphere and hot tubs in the onboard leisure areas.
• Dining Variety: Beyond complimentary options, specialty restaurants like Chops Grille and Jamie’s Italian are available for an extra fee. They can also be a good place to book a specialty meal.
• Staterooms: Royal Caribbean offers a wide range of stateroom options, from affordable interior rooms to luxurious suites. Most of their staterooms can only accommodate up to four passengers. You must call to find out about the possibility of having more than 4 people in one room. While Disney rooms are often larger, some guests find Royal Caribbean’s beds more comfortable.

My Honest Overall Opinion

I thought that Royal Caribbean would feel more comparable to Disney than it did. Here are the biggest areas that I think puts Disney ahead of Royal Caribbean.

• Kids Club: The kids club on the Disney ships is by far better, and the Oceaneer Club feels much more immersive for kids. The Royal Caribbean kids club had far less wow appeal, and felt more like a space for kids to go and be babysat vs actually wanting to hang out there.
• Dining Options: I enjoyed the food on both ships, but Disney had more options when it comes to the seated dining experiences, and for our family the food quality and consistency in those dinners gave Disney the edge. On our 7-night Royal Caribbean cruise, the dinner soup option was French onion soup FOUR times. And spaghetti bolognese was the pasta option three times! I’ve never seen meals repeat themselves so much.
• Overall Experience: The first 24 hours on Royal Caribbean felt like staying at a timeshare where we constantly had people approaching us to sell us dining packages and drink packages. We were sitting in a lounge for one drink and were approached two different times. Even our server tried selling us a kitchen tour. That got old real fast. Disney felt more immersive, while Royal Caribbean felt more sales-heavy.
• Room Service: As I mentioned already, the Royal Caribbean staff only came into our room once a day. On our Disney cruises, our room was turned over twice a day. We also got towel animals and chocolates on our bed every night with Disney. That kind of fantastic service is one reason Disney felt more polished to me.

Disney Cruise vs Royal Caribbean: Which Cruise Line is Right for You?

Choose Disney Cruise Line if:

• You’re traveling with young kids and want lots of time with Disney characters.
• You value immersive storytelling, character interactions, and the kind of themed entertainment Disney offers over big thrill rides.
• You prefer smaller ships for a more intimate cruise experience (don’t get me wrong–still a lot of people, but not compared to some of the other massive ships).
• Budget isn’t a major concern, and you’re willing to pay for a premium experience.

Choose Royal Caribbean if:

• You’re looking for large ships with diverse physical activities and extensive amenities, including things like a rock climbing wall.
• You want lower fares and a broader selection of itineraries, with frequent discounts.
• You’re seeking thrilling onboard attractions and a wide range of dining choices.
• If you want a casino on board.

Royal Caribbean and Disney both sail to private islands, so your choice may come down to whether you prefer the Castaway Cay vibe or the bigger-attraction style of CocoCay.

Ultimately, both Disney and Royal Caribbean offer incredible vacations, but the right choice depends on your family’s priorities and budget. Whether you’re setting sail with Mickey Mouse or riding the FlowRider, an unforgettable adventure awaits!

Looking at other cruise options? See if a Holland America cruise is a good fit for you. And you can find more Disney Cruise resources here:

• Disney Cruise Packing List
• Western Caribbean Cruise on the Disney Magic
• Eastern Caribbean Cruise on the Disney Fantasy